Jun thirty, 2012 #1 There are a lot of water-in-the-oil threads so I just imagined I'd personally throw this to choose from. Any water indicates a seal is leaking, and it might be as easy as an oil fill plug seal or as really hard as being a prop shaft https://outboardlowerunitstand17283.wonderkingwiki.com/1458549/the_2_minute_rule_for_mercury_outboard_motors_reviews